Should New York Consider Canceling Homeowners Insurance Like California?

California has taken some pretty drastic measures to cancel homeowners insurance policies due to the rising costs of natural disasters in the state. This has left many New Yorkers wondering if New York should consider doing the same.

Get our free mobile app

What was meant as a move to protect homeowners and reduce insurance costs in California has raised concerns with residents after state officials passed a bill that would cancel homeowners insurance policies for certain homes located in high-risk fire areas.

The move was in response to the devastating wildfires that have plagued California in recent years. The new bill affects about 350,000 homes however, it also requires insurance companies to continue coverage for an additional year to give homeowners time to find alternative options.

Homeowners across the country have been left wondering if their state might consider doing the same, including residents of Upstate New York who live in areas prone to floods and other natural disasters.

Some believe that canceling homeowners insurance policies in high-risk areas could lead to even bigger problems in the long run. For example, if a major flood were to happen in Upstate New York, something the residents of the Southern Tier are quite familiar with, many homeowners would be left with no coverage and simply no way to recover financially. Additionally, canceling homeowner insurance policies could make it impossible for buyers to obtain mortgages as lenders require proof of insurance.

On the other hand, some argue that canceling homeowners insurance could be a good thing for some New Yorkers as it would nudge people to take better care of their homes and properties. Additionally, if homeowners insurance were to be canceled in high-risk areas, such as flood zones, it could lead to a redistribution of risk across the insurance market and potentially lower premiums for homeowners who live in safer areas.

Right now there are no plans in the works for New York to cancel homeowners insurance as California has, however, the conversation has begun. Either way, while canceling homeowners insurance could result in lower costs for some homeowners, it also could leave other homeowners exposed to catastrophic risks.